How to mix Blender with robotics simulators (such as Grasshopper) to produce school classes

"@Assistant Grasshopper versus RoboDK versus V-REP versus Gazebo (plus other such tools)? Which can you use with Blender?"

[This post allows all uses]

Responses from artificial intelligences (Anthropic’s “Assistant” / “Claude-3-Haiku” / “Gemini-1.5-Flash”), careful how you interpret such responses:

Claude-3-Haiku: Understood. Let me provide an overview of the key differences between Grasshopper, RoboDK, V-REP, and Gazebo, and how they can potentially be used in conjunction with Blender:

Grasshopper:

- A visual programming interface for 3D modeling and design, with strong capabilities for simulating physics and kinematics.

- Can be integrated with Blender through plugins like Weaverbird and Grasshopper-Blender, allowing 3D models and animations to be shared between the two tools.

RoboDK:

- A dedicated software for simulation, programming, and offline programming of industrial robotic systems.

- Provides a comprehensive environment for modeling robots, planning motions, and generating robot programming code.

- Can export robot programs to a wide range of industrial robot controllers, including KUKA and Fanuc.

- While not directly integrated with Blender, models created in Blender can be imported into RoboDK for simulation and programming purposes.

V-REP (now discontinued, replaced by CoppeliaSim):

- A general-purpose robot simulation platform with a focus on research and educational applications.

- Offers a visual programming interface similar to Grasshopper, as well as the ability to import 3D models from various CAD and 3D modeling tools, including Blender.

- Provides advanced physics simulation, sensor modeling, and robot control capabilities.

Gazebo:

- A popular open-source robot simulation environment, often used in robotics research and education.

- Primarily focused on simulating outdoor and mobile robots, but can also handle industrial robotic arms.

- Can be integrated with Blender through plugins, allowing 3D models and scenes to be shared between the two tools.

In summary, when considering the use of these tools with Blender:

- Grasshopper provides a strong tie-in with Blender, allowing for seamless integration of 3D modeling, physics simulation, and kinematics.

- RoboDK offers a specialized environment for industrial robot simulation and programming, with the ability to import Blender models.

- V-REP (CoppeliaSim) and Gazebo provide more general-purpose robot simulation capabilities that can also be used in conjunction with Blender.

The choice of which tool(s) to use would depend on the specific educational or project requirements, such as the type of robots being simulated, the level of detail needed in the physics and kinematics, and the desired integration with 3D modeling and animation workflows.

Gemini-1.5-Flash: You're asking about the compatibility of Blender with various robotics simulation and programming platforms. Here's a breakdown:

* **Grasshopper:** While Grasshopper is primarily a visual programming interface for Rhino 3D, it can be used to control external applications, including Blender. You can use Grasshopper to define parameters and scripts that control Blender's actions, like object creation, animation, and rendering. However, this requires setting up custom plugins and scripting, making it a more advanced and less straightforward integration.

* **RoboDK:** RoboDK is a popular platform for robot simulation and programming. It offers direct integration with Blender through its "Blender Importer" plugin. This allows you to import Blender models into RoboDK for robot path planning, simulation, and code generation. RoboDK excels in its focus on industrial robots and provides a user-friendly interface for programming robot tasks.

* **V-REP:** V-REP (Virtual Robot Experimentation Platform) is a powerful and versatile platform for robotics simulation. It offers a Python API that can be used to control Blender from within V-REP. This allows you to create and animate Blender models within the V-REP environment, enabling you to simulate robot interactions with them. V-REP is known for its advanced physics simulation capabilities and support for a wide range of robot models.

* **Gazebo:** Gazebo is a widely used robotics simulator developed by the Open Source Robotics Foundation (OSRF). While it doesn't have direct integration with Blender, you can use Gazebo's plugin system to create custom plugins that interact with Blender. This allows you to import Blender models into Gazebo and simulate robot interactions with them. Gazebo is known for its advanced physics simulation, support for various sensors, and its open-source nature.

**Other Tools:**

* **Simulink (MATLAB):** Simulink can be used for robotics simulation and control, and it offers interfaces for connecting with external applications, including Blender. You can use Simulink to design control systems and simulate robot behavior, and then visualize these simulations in Blender.

* **ROS (Robot Operating System):** ROS is a widely used framework for robotics development. You can use ROS tools to control and simulate robots, and then visualize these simulations in Blender. ROS offers a variety of libraries and tools for robot programming, sensor integration, and communication.

**Choosing the Right Tool:**

The best tool for you depends on your specific needs and goals. Consider factors like:

* **Ease of Integration:** RoboDK offers the most straightforward integration with Blender, followed by V-REP and Gazebo. Grasshopper requires more advanced scripting and plugin development.

* **Physics Simulation Capabilities:** V-REP and Gazebo are known for their advanced physics simulation capabilities, while RoboDK focuses more on industrial robot simulation.

* **Programming Interface:** RoboDK, V-REP, and Gazebo offer various programming interfaces (Python, C++, etc.) for controlling simulations and interacting with Blender models.

* **Robot Models and Sensors:** V-REP and Gazebo offer support for a wide range of robot models and sensors, while RoboDK focuses on industrial robots.

Ultimately, the best way to determine the best tool for your needs is to experiment with them and see which one best suits your workflow and project requirements.

View more of this conversation's texts

Visuals:

Has to do with this:

Source codes:

https://github.com/SwuduSusuwu/SubStack/issues/2

KUKA’s/Fanucs: